Staccato HD P4 vs OA Defense 2311 Compact Pro: Magazine Wars in the 2011 Platform
When it comes to modern double-stack 1911-style pistols, few comparisons are more compelling than the Staccato HD P4 versus the OA Defense 2311 Compact Pro. Both pistols are purpose-built for performance, duty use, and concealed carry — yet they take entirely different paths when it comes to design philosophy, frame construction, and magazine compatibility.
Here’s a look at what sets each platform apart.
The Staccato HD P4 is a 9mm pistol that blends traditional 1911 performance with modern innovations. Built on a 4140 billet steel frame, the P4 is designed to absorb recoil and offer stability during rapid fire. It comes with a 4-inch DLC-coated bull barrel, flat wire recoil system, and a single-action trigger that breaks around 4–4.5 lbs.
What truly distinguishes the P4 is its Glock-style magazine compatibility. Rather than sticking with proprietary 2011 magazines, the P4 ships with two 18-round Mec-Gar steel magazines modeled after Glock geometry. This significantly reduces cost and improves availability for shooters who already use Glock mags across multiple platforms.
Optics-ready from the factory, the pistol supports co-witnessing with a forward-mounted combat-style rear sight. When paired with premium optics like the Trijicon RMR HD, the setup becomes highly efficient for both duty and competitive applications.
The OA Defense 2311 Compact Pro takes a very different approach. Built with an aluminum frame, this pistol is lighter and faster on target — ideal for shooters prioritizing maneuverability. Unlike many compact 2011 variants, the Compact Pro is ported from the factory, helping reduce muzzle rise during rapid shooting.
It features fully ambidextrous controls, aggressive Talon-style grip texturing, and includes five Sig P320 magazines right out of the box — an impressive value proposition for those already invested in the Sig ecosystem.
The pistol also ships with optic mounting plates for all major footprints and uses a forward-mounted rear sight to allow for clean co-witnessing with most red dots.
Beyond specs and features, this comparison ultimately comes down to magazine ecosystems.
Glock magazines are renowned for their affordability, wide availability, and robust aftermarket support.
Sig P320 magazines are factory-backed, reliable, and gaining ground in both civilian and law enforcement circles.
For shooters already invested in one platform, these pistols offer compelling crossover opportunities — without forcing a complete gear reset.
Both the Staccato HD P4 and the OA Defense 2311 Compact Pro represent the evolution of the 2011-style handgun. Whether it's the P4’s all-steel feel and Glock mag flexibility or the 2311’s lightweight build, factory porting, and Sig compatibility, each platform is purpose-driven and feature-rich.
Looking for more comparisons, parts breakdowns, and reviews?
Follow RazorMP on Instagram (@razor.mp) and X (@RazorMP_actual) for behind-the-scenes content, live range footage, and upcoming reviews.
