Eight-Way Striker-Fired Pistol Comparison: Ported & Comped Models Tested

Factory-integrated porting and compensation are no longer rare features reserved for custom shops. More manufacturers are offering pistols ready to tame recoil right out of the box. To put these claims to the test, I compared eight striker-fired pistols side by side—each equipped with either factory porting or a compensator.

The Pistols Tested

• CZ P-10C Ported – Compact frame with a heavier barrel and single top port, built for precision.
• Smith & Wesson M&P M2.0 Compact Carry Comp – Carry-size pistol with S&W’s integral comp port and tritium front sight.
• Springfield Armory Echelon 4.0C Comp – Compact Echelon with a hammer-forged barrel and integral compensator.
• Tisas PX-9 Duty Comp – Budget entry with RMR cut, multiple grip configurations, and integrated porting.
• SIG Sauer P365 XMacro Comp – Ultra-thin carry gun with an integrally compensated slide and 17+1 capacity.
• Canik Mete MC9 Prime – Comped slide and ported barrel with a flat-faced trigger and G-Code holster included.
• Derya DY9 Island – Glock 19-style pistol with an island barrel design and direct RMR cut.
• Shadow Systems XR920P (Bronze Barrel) – Premium model with a proprietary comp system for flat, fast shooting.

This range covers everything from budget-friendly to premium, with performance differences that reflect the price spread.

Testing Conditions

Each pistol was run through the same drills for consistency:

• Accuracy: Targets set at 35 feet (just under 12 yards) from a rest position.
• Rapid Fire: Fifteen-round strings fired at 25 feet (around 8 yards).

Velocitas solid copper 9mm ammunition was used across all pistols to keep results consistent.

Performance Highlights

• Accuracy Leader: The CZ P-10C Ported stood out with the tightest groups.
• Speed & Splits: The Springfield Echelon 4.0C Comp and Tisas PX-9 Duty Comp pushed the fastest times.
• Quickest First Shots: The Canik Mete MC9 Prime excelled in fast-on-target performance.
• Premium Control: The Shadow Systems XR920P provided top-tier handling and controllability, even when not leading in raw numbers.

It’s important to remember that results vary with the shooter. These findings reflect how each pistol performed in one set of hands on one range day. Different shooters may see different outcomes.

Takeaways

• For value, the Tisas PX-9 Duty Comp delivers impressive features at a budget price.
• For precision, the CZ P-10C Ported is hard to beat.
• For premium performance, the Shadow Systems XR920P earns its top-shelf reputation.

Overall, all eight pistols confirm why factory porting and compensation are gaining popularity—they provide real-world advantages in recoil management and shot recovery without requiring aftermarket modifications.

Resources & Partners

• Ammo used: Velocitas solid copper 9mm
• Supporters: Scottsdale Tactical, G-Code

For full gear lists, discount codes, and additional reviews, visit www.razormp.com.

Follow for more firearm insights and reviews:

• Instagram: @razor.mp
• X (Twitter): @RazorMP_Actual